Views: 92 Author: Site Editor Publish Time: 2026-11-06 Origin: Site
Choose the system that delivers the required beverage quality and batch volume at an acceptable operating cost. A well-run sheet filter can remain a practical choice where the equipment is already installed and changeovers fit the production schedule. A lenticular system is worth evaluating when handling individual sheets, containing the product or fitting filtration into a transfer window creates a measurable problem.
Both formats can use related depth media. Scott Laboratories describes lenticular modules as an alternative packaging of media used for similar beverage duties. Compare the proposed grades and operating conditions before comparing equipment totals. Use these differences to set comparable media and equipment requirements in the purchasing specification.
For the media, housing and trial information needed to specify a module system, use our lenticular filter selection guide for industrial buyers.
Match the clarification target and media performance before comparing formats.
Assess the actual containment and drainage design of each quoted machine.
Measure the whole changeover, including hardware cleaning and product recovery.
Compare total filtration cost against the volume that meets the agreed specification.
A beverage plate-and-frame depth filter holds individual sheets between plates. The equipment establishes feed and filtrate channels and compresses the filter pack. Sheet orientation, condition and installation are part of the operating procedure. Eaton's sheet instructions identify the inlet and outlet sides and describe preparation for use. Depth filter sheet installation guidance
Lenticular filter cartridges package circular depth filter cells around a core inside a housing. The media and drainage structure form a replaceable assembly. Pall's technical overview describes the relationship between depth sheets and stacked disc construction. The module grade still determines the separation duty for which it should be tested. For LOONGFiltration media options, review the lenticular filter range with the supplier.
Here, plate and frame means a sheet-based beverage clarification system. If your duty requires cake formation, precoat or solids discharge, include those requirements in a separate equipment assessment when reviewing a filter press vs lenticular filter proposal.
Give each supplier the same liquid and outlet target. Ask for the grade, effective area and basis of the retention rating. A meaningful comparison uses representative production feed at the intended temperature, with the flow per unit area and stopping criteria recorded.
Comparison item | Plate-and-frame depth filter | Lenticular depth filter |
|---|---|---|
Media identification | Sheet grade, dimensions and number installed | Module code, grade, area and number installed |
Installation check | Orientation, sheet condition and pack assembly | Connection, seals, supports and seating |
Run endpoint | Agreed quality, pressure or flow endpoint | The same agreed endpoint under comparable conditions |
Product assessment | Outlet quality and accepted volume | The same outlet tests and volume accounting |
Changeover record | Loading, removal, hardware cleaning and restart | Module handling, hardware cleaning and restart |
When the packaged product needs microbial control, define the final treatment and its validation in the process specification. Pall's wine guidance calls for microorganism-specific retention evidence and integrity testing of final filters. Keep that requirement visible when assessing either clarification format. State these downstream controls in the system specification before comparing clarification equipment.
Time the work operators actually perform. For sheets, include unpacking, placement, pack assembly and removal. For modules, include access to the housing, wet module handling and any lifting equipment. Check the available floor space and removal clearance using the supplier's drawing.
Compare containment against the machine design. Conventional sheet filters and enclosed plate-and-frame equipment are both available. Eaton's BECO INTEGRA PLATE A600 EC, for example, uses an external chamber around the sheet pack. Ask how each proposed machine contains leakage and how its liquid is recovered or drained. An enclosed plate-and-frame configuration
For an oxygen-sensitive beverage, use the site's sampling method to measure pickup across the complete installation. Record startup separately if it behaves differently from steady transfer. Include hoses, connections and the recovery method in the trial so the result describes the equipment you intend to operate.
Specify how the product-contact hardware will be cleaned after spent media is removed. Then assess any proposed regeneration of the medium. The vessel, plates and fittings need their own cleaning procedure even when the media is replaced after a run.
Reuse permission depends on the selected product. Eaton documents backwashing for specified depth sheets. Pall's module instructions distinguish designs with different permitted flow directions. Obtain the instructions for the exact sheet or module and define the performance checks needed before its next use. Use our lenticular filter system setup checklist to identify the mounting parts and model-specific instructions to request.
Record accepted volume on each demonstrated use, together with preparation time and cleaning consumption. Ask the supplier how it will assess deterioration and establish replacement criteria. Those records provide the basis for a reuse allowance in the operating budget.
Use the same production period and quality specification for both offers. Divide the total filtration-related cost by the volume accepted for the next process stage or release. Establish that volume from the site's recovery and quality records.
Cost item | Information to collect |
|---|---|
Equipment | Purchase and installation costs allocated over the chosen evaluation period |
Consumables | Actual sheet or module use, including discarded and regenerated media |
Labor | Preparation, supervision, removal, cleaning and restart time |
Utilities and waste | Rinse liquid, cleaning agents, energy and disposal |
Product recovery | Accepted output and product left in equipment or discarded at transitions |
Interrupted production | Measured delays or additional handling within the batch schedule |
For an existing sheet filter, establish this baseline before calculating the benefit of conversion. A new installation needs quotations for both complete systems, including instruments and accessories. Keep initial equipment fill, liquid retained after draining and final unrecovered product as separate entries in the trial record.
Retain the existing sheet system when it meets quality and scheduling requirements at a measured cost the business accepts. Shortlist a lenticular filter system when a trial shows a practical improvement in the operating problem that prompted the review. Include an enclosed sheet system in the shortlist when containment is the main selection criterion.
Send the suppliers the liquid description, batch range and transfer window. Include the present media grade and run records, the outlet tests and the cleaning procedure. Request each proposed grade and area in writing, with a drawing showing the connections and service access.
LOONGFiltration offers composite depth lenticular filters and lenticular filter housings. Review those parts as a matched configuration. Its application pages provide starting points for discussing beer filtration and wine filtration.
Compare the documented media grades and trial results. Module geometry describes the package, while retention depends on the selected medium and operating conditions.
Yes. Enclosed sheet equipment is commercially available. Evaluate its chamber, sealing interfaces and drainage against the containment requirement for the proposed module housing. Request the drawings and operating instructions for the enclosed configuration under review.
Use a representative batch trial to measure accepted product recovery. Record startup transitions, draining and the recovery procedure. Apply the same accounting method to each configuration.
Compare the accepted volume recovered after each demonstrated cleaning cycle with its preparation and cleaning costs. Include replacement criteria and any storage work in the calculation.
Send LOONGFiltration your present equipment details, media grade and recent batch record. State the quality target and the operating problem you want to improve so the proposed module system can be compared with your existing process. Request a filtration selection discussion. You can also visit the LOONGFiltration website or browse the official YouTube channel.